The Supreme Court’s decision against Dalmia Cement’s land acquisition raises uncomfortable questions about government approvals, corporate influence and the protection of tribal land rights.
BHUBANESWAR, November 21: The Supreme Court’s November 18 judgment quashing land acquisition for Dalmia Cement’s mining expansion in Sundargarh is more than a victory for residents of three villages. It is a warning about how the state exercises its powers when private mining interests encounter community resistance.
The case concerns approximately 273.57 hectares of land in Kukuda, Bihabandha and Lanjiberna.
The Gram Sabhas had rejected the acquisition proposal in January 2020. Yet the Odisha government proceeded with acquisition notifications in 2021.
The Supreme Court found that the mandatory prior consent of the Gram Sabhas had not been obtained. It also held that the acquisition required consent from at least 80% of affected families because the land was being acquired for a private company.
The first question is straightforward: Who authorised the acquisition process despite the recorded objections of the Gram Sabhas?
An independent assessment—or a compromised process?
The judgment raises another serious concern.The Social Impact Assessment process lacked the required public hearing. More significantly, the expert group examining the assessment included a land-acquisition adviser associated with Dalmia Cement.
The Supreme Court described the compromised deliberation as a “fixed match.”
How could a committee expected to independently scrutinise the social consequences of acquisition include an adviser to the beneficiary company?
Who approved that appointment, and will the government examine the officials responsible?
What about Odisha’s other mining projects?The implications extend beyond Lanjiberna.Mining proposals in Scheduled Areas across Odisha, including those facing community objections, deserve scrutiny against the legal standards reaffirmed by the Court.
That does not automatically invalidate other mining leases, forest clearances or land acquisitions. The applicable legal requirements and compliance records must be examined project by project.
But the government should now disclose how many mining-related acquisitions in Scheduled Areas have proceeded without documented prior consent, legally compliant Social Impact Assessments or properly constituted expert groups.
The judgment also establishes an important distinction: a mining lease does not automatically confer the right to occupy privately held land without lawful acquisition.
The disputed acquisition advanced in 2021 under the previous BJD government. The present BJP government must now decide how to respond to the Supreme Court’s findings and whether to examine comparable acquisitions.
The Court has left the state free to initiate fresh acquisition proceedings, but only in accordance with the law.
The immediate questions are whether the government will review the officials’ decisions, make the acquisition records public and independently examine compliance in other Scheduled Areas.
Lanjiberna has exposed a fundamental accountability issue: when the law requires community consent, can the state treat that consent as an obstacle to be overcome rather than a right to be respected?
The Supreme Court has answered the legal question. Odisha’s administration must now answer the questions about responsibility.

